Good morning, teachers! You’re listening to episode # 7.
Today we are talking about the difference between feedback and grading...and why grading everything isn’t all that helpful.
Grading an assignment tells a student which problems were done incorrectly. Feedback explains why problems were done incorrectly.
Gosh, this is so hard for me to chat about as a math teacher...not only because I have made mistakes, but because personally as a student...I was motivated by grades. So when I first stepped into that classroom, the idea that a grade might not actually be a motivator for students took me a while to digest.
Do you ever feel the same way? Or maybe you were the student who wasn’t motivated by a grade? Either way, let’s chat about how we can reframe our mindset about grades and provide purposeful feedback to students while also lessening our grading workload.
Let’s do it!
There is a big difference between grading and feedback, but I think those terms can often be confused for one another. Grading is the act of taking something and holding it to a scale of some sort. Feedback is evaluative or corrective information about an action, event, or process to the original or controlling source...that is straight from the Merriam-Webster online dictionary.
So in an example of a student completing an assignment, grading is the process of measuring the assignment against the key or rubric...the scale...and a student would receive a score based on that. Whereas, for that same assignment, feedback would be sharing something evaluative or corrective about that assignment.
When I say that at first, it sounds like feedback is a lot more work! And I think it can be if you are trying to correct every little thing…so let’s see if we can dispel this idea and construct a plan to have you giving more feedback and grading less.
Grading is like a hamster wheel that you can get on and can’t seem to get off. It goes something like this…
Give an assignment to students, majority of students complete and turn in an assignment, grade each assignment, remind students of missing assignments, put grades into the grade book, collect any late work, have piles of late work to grade, assign a new assignment, majority of students complete and turn in assignment… get missing assignments for students who were absent, received a late paper from two weeks ago…
Grading too many papers is tedious and time-consuming...it requires a ridiculous amount of paper management...it requires you to get missing assignments from students who were absent or didn’t complete them the first time….it requires you to actually grade and return it in a time frame that the grade is still meaningful...and with all the internet tools available to students...it may not even be a full reflection of students mastery.
Yikes! That doesn’t sound like an effective use of your time! Remember that 80/20 rule we talked about in last week's episode...it applies to grading too!
“Grading everything does not further motivate students who would already lack the motivation to do the work. Students who are highly motivated are going to complete their assignments regardless of whether or not the assignments are graded. While grades are meant to hold students accountable for completing their work, for some students, it creates numerous “incompletes” that are overwhelming for both student and teacher.” - Tyne Brack
So should you grade nothing?.. Well, we don’t want to go to that extreme...but I will say we can purposefully plan our grading so that we aren’t expending too much energy with little result.
One thing I want to share is that many schools and teachers are adopting standards-based grading for these very reasons. I want to spend time talking about standards-based grading, but I think that deserves its own episode as there are many things to break down and I want to give it the time it requires. So we will revisit this topic.
Now the question becomes, why do we grade? As a math teacher, I think the desire to grade comes from a genuine place of wanting to know how your students are progressing with the content. Since math builds upon itself so quickly, we really want to know where a student is and catch those misconceptions quickly. This is why I think feedback is something to consider...And I would venture to guess that you are giving feedback throughout the day without even realizing it.
Some things to consider when grading:
- #1, You do want to make sure you are following your school's guidelines. Some schools have consistent grading values or weights or requirements like two test grades per grading period. That is something out of your control and boundaries that you should work within.
- #2, What formative assessment... like a quick check, mini quiz, or exit ticket...can you grade for mastery on a specific concept? I like these types of grades because they are typically short and can be both graded and returned to students quickly plus they reflect a demonstration of mastery.
- #3, Can you consolidate grades? I know some schools have a grading system that accounts for classwork or homework. Can you consolidate those grades from several per week to once per week? I used a homework agenda that allowed me to not only consolidate my grading but also the time I spent inputting grades into a grade book.
One other thing to consider is a grade can seem very final for students. Some students are motivated by this, but I really think about the students who struggle but really are putting forth effort and how feedback can be more beneficial and motivating than a grade on a piece of paper. Feedback signifies that there is room for improvement and keeps the learning loop open.
Feedback can be a variety of different things from a quick conversation, to notes on a paper, to pulling a small group.
My son is in kindergarten and one thing that his teacher really emphasizes is handwriting! He gets all sorts of feedback from her and she will correct his letter formation. This is useful for him to see that the lowercase s needs to go all the way to the bottom line (or whatever you call that), but it isn’t saying because your s didn’t go to the bottom line you lost points.
So let’s walk through all the ways you can give feedback to your students...many of which you are likely already doing.
Pulling a small group of students...any time you are working with a small group of students you are able to give feedback to them in real-time. You are able to see any misconceptions, ask scaffolding questions, and even challenge them in their thinking process. That small group time is so valuable for any student, not just those who are struggling with the content. I have been talking about the 80/20 rule quite a bit, and I am convinced that pulling small groups of students will yield you an incredible impact.
It could be a quick conversation at a student’s desk or at your desk. When I taught math intervention classes, I was often able to review specific assignments and activities one on one with students. This was ideal!
Let’s say your time is limited, you can do a whole group error analysis of a specific question. You can work the problem incorrectly using a misconception that you frequently see, which will lead to a great class discussion. This could be as simple as an exit ticket question or a test question. Students are not only getting feedback from you, but they are also getting feedback from students. This is similar to the instructional strategy commonly known as “my favorite no.”
Another idea is to use a video to repurpose your feedback! One of our MTM teachers, Marissa, teaches a hybrid model shared with me this summer that she uses flipgrid to make little videos of herself solving the problem. Then she just cuts and copies the link as feedback to the students -- talk about working smarter not harder and sooooo much easier than trying to type a comment.
Lastly, I wanted to tackle missing work woes and provide a few things to consider and ideas to try.
- First, really evaluate how many assignments you are trying to grade and keep track of. Can you reduce that number?
- What is a reasonable amount of work for students to do and for you to grade?
Secondly, can you create a process that minimizes missing work? If you haven’t listened to episode #2 on setting students up for success, then be sure to check that out.
Here are a few ideas
- Have everything due on the same day of the week. Students that need more time can work on their assignments in class, while students that have completed the work can participate in a fun activity.
- Utilize things that auto-grade with Google Forms or software like GoFormative.
- Consider a replacement grade? One thing that I hated was finding missing papers or assignments for students towards the end of the grading period. If you have a replacement activity then it will save you trying to locate the specific page they are missing. I would do this with the test review. Test reviews would replace any missing assignments from that grading period which highly motivated students to get it done!
- Consider dropping the lowest grade of the grading period (not a test grade) that gives students some grace and is beneficial to all students who did the work on time.
These are all simple solutions to the missing work woes that you might be facing.
Before we wrap up, I wanted to remind you about a few updates that we have made to our Maneuvering the Middle resources. First, for those of you who are embracing the auto-grading feature of Google Forms, we recently updated our digital unit assessment pack to include both tests and quizzes and our Test Prep unit has all new Google Form quick checks!
So as a quick recap... if you want to minimize your time spent grading and still ensure that students are mastering the concepts… consider giving feedback to students as an alternative to grading...we chatted about what assignments lend themselves to this and how you can give feedback both individually, in a small group, or as a whole class.
Remember that ever famous 80/20 rule and focus on the 20% of things that will have the biggest impact on your students, your classroom, and your overall quality of life. That rule also applies to grading!
We are several weeks into our Good Morning Teacher podcast, and it has been a joy to record these for you! I am hoping that they are making your commute to work a little more enjoyable and that you are able to take ideas and make them work in your classroom. If you have been loving the podcast, then we would love a five-star review! It helps us to get found by other teachers! For more all of the links, resources, and freebies mentioned today in one easy place, so check out maneuveringthemiddle.com/episode7.
I’m Noelle Pickering… and you’ve been listening to the Good Morning Teacher podcast… Until next time, friends, make it a great week!