Good morning, teachers! You’re listening to episode # 5.
Today...is an episode that I know is much needed, and honestly...I thought twice about recording this topic...I am nervous because I know that each and every school and administrator is different...we all have different relationships with administrators...but I know it is really needed right now. Teaching expectations are at an all-time high and as the year progresses I know there will be things that carry over to next year...so I want you to be prepared.
I am discussing what it looks like to productively advocate for yourself to your administrators.
Let’s jump in!
The idea of this podcast came from a blog post that we shared back in 2018 that resonated with many teachers. The concept that you can advocate for yourself, just like you may advocate for a student or for your own child or family member. I saw this first hand growing up, when my mom advocated for my brother and his learning needs for at least a decade...there is really nothing that can stop a mom on a mission to support their child.
I think teachers do this all the time, as well...we have a student who has a need and we go to all the people and expend the resources to ensure they have what they need. I can recall a former student of mine who needed glasses… by working with the counselor we were able to help this student get a prescription and the glasses they needed.
You are already doing this for so many people in your life. Why do we not do it for ourselves?
I think there are a lot of reasons that teachers struggle to advocate for themselves...first, you may not have a relationship with your administration, or they may seem unapproachable...secondly, there seems to be a general culture in teaching that you just figure it out, you deal with it and then move on and make it work...and thirdly, from personal experience... I have never taught at a school where one of the primary goals was for teachers to be stakeholders in the process and decision making...Because of this when big decisions were made, either teachers weren’t included, or there was not a culture where you could voice opposition.
Now, I want to pause and give a disclaimer because schools are so different, they have different goals, administrators with different leadership styles, and school climate can vary widely. So, you may need to tweak these points in your situation. The more rapport that you have with your administrators, the more likely you are to see success. If you have only been at that campus for a month and have not established a ton of credibility, you may have to wait or just approach it differently.
My personality is very much one that respects authority,“deals with the change” and moves on. It wasn’t until late in my teaching career that I was able to change my mindset that voicing a concern was not the same as complaining. Now sometimes those are one in the same and I think that is exactly what we want to avoid...and what I will share today.
However, to be transparent, I was not good at advocating for myself. In fact, one year, my husband and I had moved across the state and I found myself in a new role at a new campus. It was really hard. The culture was very much top-down and I felt this need to prove myself. There were all sorts of instructional decisions being made that I didn’t think were best for my students and in retrospect, I knew I was a good teacher! I had proven results in all my years of teaching and I wish I had been confident enough to ask for a meeting with my administrators to gain clarity. Instead, I was always stressed and dreaded going to work each and every day. I cried every morning on my way to work and romanticized the alternate job I was offered...and as the spring semester came...I spent countless hours searching for a better position.
When I went to tell them I had taken a new position, my administrators were shocked, they were disappointed, and they shared how valued I had been...however, I never felt that. This issue was two-sided. Had I advocated for myself, I may have been able to work through the challenges and probably could have improved our school culture...they may have been more aware of what teachers were feeling. I’ll never know.
So...let’s talk through what steps you can take as a teacher to productively advocate for yourself...keyword...productively.
Step 1: Stop Complaining
First, you have to stop complaining.
Complaining is an easy way out that makes us feel better...but doesn’t actually solve the problem. Have you ever told someone, “I just need to vent”? You and me both!
The problem with complaining is three-fold. First, when we complain, we are almost always complaining to people with no power to fix the problem. Think about all of the teacher Facebook groups where you see people complaining about a situation on their campus. The people in that group don’t have any power to solve the problem. What usually happens is a big thread of discussion about their related problems. You may feel better because you said something, but is your situation actually changing?
We do this to our family, friends, and colleagues, too. How many times have you vented to someone you know? You usually feel better afterwards, but the next day when you walk into work, your situation hasn’t changed.
Secondly, when we complain, we can start to develop a reputation of “being a complainer” and that reputation is hard to change. You can probably think of a few coworkers with this reputation right now! We don’t want to develop that reputation ourselves, because when we do have the courage to voice a concern or suggest a possible solution or do any of the steps I am going to share today, people’s perception of us will determine how much they are willing to listen or validate your point of view.
Third, it takes our mental energy and focuses it on a problem, rather than a solution.
I am not advocating that you can’t complain or that you should bottle it all up. I am saying that complaining is not a form of problem-solving and so when things don’t change you shouldn’t be surprised.
Okay, so we have stopped complaining about the problem….now how can we actually fix it?!
Step 2: Ask for Face to Face Time
Resist that urge to send a lengthy email outlining your concerns....email can be hard to decipher and convey tone...it can be easily skimmed so you may not be fully heard...and then, what if you don’t get an immediate response...you will be left uncomfortably waiting...not even knowing if your concerns have been heard.
Also, try to resist the urge to drop by your administrator’s office at lunch or between the bell. It is best to get on the calendar of your administration. This allows you to clearly communicate, for them to be fully focused on your concerns, and allows you to convey a specific tone that is difficult to do in writing. Have you ever misread the tone in a text message only to realize it was meant differently? I think we all have!
So, my suggestion is to send a message asking for face-to-face time. It could be as simple as:
Hi Admin,
I would like your assistance in solving a problem that I have encountered lately and have a few ideas that I would like to share with you.
What day and time are you available for us to meet?
Sincerely,
Noelle
It really is that simple. If you don’t hear back in 48 hours, then follow up.
Step 3: Come Prepared
So this is where your prep work comes in and where the idea of productively advocating gets the name productive. If you walk into the meeting with only the problem outlined, then you are subject to either 1) no immediate solution or 2) whatever solution your administrator offers after initially hearing the issue.
I think the other thing to note is that a lot of times we don’t convey the why behind the struggle. Why is this an issue? Is it only an issue for you? Does it impact your students? Is it impacting your team, department, or a larger segment of the campus?
Those are all important things to share without throwing anyone under the bus.
It would be a good idea to make a brief outline, sharing the following:
- What it is you are struggling with
- How you and others are impacted by this and why it is a challenge
- 2-3 possible solutions that you have thought through
Once you have your ideas fleshed out, it is probably worth practicing, especially if you are like me and have trouble voicing concerns. Practice in front of the mirror or call up a friend to have them listen. You don’t need to have a speech memorized by any means, but you do want to be able to clearly articulate your thoughts.
I tend to personally get choked up when I think I am disappointing someone and have benefited tremendously from practicing.
Step 4: Offer Possible Solutions
So, I just mentioned bringing solutions to the meeting as one way to be prepared. Let’s flesh that out a little more so that you can be more successful and achieve the desired outcome.
These possible solutions don’t have to be perfect...they do have to be genuine. So for example, in my situation, had I brought in some data to show that the specific instructional component wasn’t doing what they wanted, then that might have been helpful in communicating why I didn’t think it was a good idea. It certainly goes a lot further than had I just said that I didn’t like it.
By brainstorming possible ideas, you are conveying that you want to make this work and that you can be part of the solution as well. It is also MUCH easier for your administrator to agree to your course of action than to leave them with the burden of finding a solution on their own. Plus, with possible ideas ready to go, you may be able to solve the problem in one meeting and have an immediate resolution. This is a win-win! You were able to get to a solution that you felt good about and your administrator was able to clear up your concern with minimal time involved.
These possible solutions communicate a willingness and a genuine commitment to making your school a better working environment for teachers and a better learning environment for your students. I firmly believe that teachers who love coming to work, make for a place that students love coming to learn.
Step 5: Meet and Follow Up
Now, you have prepared and practiced...you are ready to walk into your meeting with confidence! Remember that you are a valuable part of your school community and that your ideas are important! You want to be honest and sincere and communicate that because you love your school or your job or your students or whatever the reason, you want them to be aware of the problem and you would like their help in solving the problem.
In an ideal world, you can come to a solution within that 30-minute meeting. That is fabulous!
If that is the case, then I recommend that you follow up with an email thanking them and briefly outline what was discussed. This helps to ensure you are both on the same page going forward.
More than likely, you may have to wait, there may be something or someone that your administrator has to work with to find a solution. If that is the case, I recommend leaving the meeting by saying that you will follow up in a week. It certainly doesn’t hurt to send that same thank you email afterwards, but then put it on your calendar to circle back if there is still not a solution.
Administrators are pretty busy and your situation may not be a priority for them, so follow up is crucial. But understand that there may not be a quick solution that can be implemented right away.
And, I know that I have teachers listening that are thinking “this would never fly at my campus” and maybe that is the case...if so, you may have to reevaluate if that is the campus for you. Potentially there are many other positives! Or maybe like me, you need to find a better fit.
Either way, I hope you learn from my experience and do try to productively advocate for yourself!
So as a quick recap... productively advocating for yourself can be done … First, stop complaining. Second...ask for face to face time, third...come prepared, ready to clearly articulate the problem, and fourth...outlining some possible solutions, and fifth...follow up.
You will be proud of yourself for going through the process and working to change the school culture that pushes against it.
We are several weeks into our Good Morning Teacher podcast, and it has been a joy to record these for you! I am hoping that they are making your commute to work a little more enjoyable and that you are able to take ideas and make them work in your classroom. If you have been loving the podcast, then we would love a five star review! It helps other teachers find us! For all of the links, resources, and freebies mentioned today in one easy place, check out maneuveringthemiddle.com/episode5.
I’m Noelle Pickering… and you’ve been listening to the Good Morning Teacher podcast… Until next time, friends, make it a great week!